Contemporary Reception History
Short Reviews/mentions (60 words or less):
"Porter, Mrs Eleanor (Hodgeman)."Booklist, Vol. 16, No. 10, 1 June 1920: 350.
The Times [London] Literary Supplement, 30 Sept. 1920:637.
Rev. of Mary Marie, by Eleanor H. Porter. The Spectator Supplement 3 Dec. 1920:782; Quoted in Book Review Digest
1920, 433-434, Vol. 9, New York: H.W. Wilson and Company, 1921.
Long Reviews (more than 60 words):
"Mary Marie." Rev. of Mary Marie, by Eleanor H. Porter. New York Times Book Review 4 July 1920:26,28.
Rev. of Mary Marie, by Eleanor H. Porter. Boston Transcript, 29 May 1920:8; Quoted in Book Review Digest
1920, 433-434, Vol. 9, New York: H.W. Wilson and Company, 1921.
Rev. of Mary Marie, by Eleanor H. Porter. The Springfield Republican 11 July 1920:11a; Quoted in Book Review Digest
1920, 433-434, Vol. 9, New York: H.W. Wilson and Company, 1921.
Summary of Mary Marie's Contemporary Reception History
Book reviews of Eleanor H. Porter's
Mary Marie were generally positive about the novel. "The book is very readable, and occasionally amusing," said one critic in an early
Boston Transcript Review.
Mary Marie also charmed the
New York Times Book Review and
Springfield Republican critics with her first person narrative. "Beneath the light tone of the narrative may be observed a serious moral...but Mary Marie will be loved for he
rself alone," wrote the Springfield Republican critic. The Times Book Review critic notes that Mary Marie grows to face the same problem of divorce as her parents: "But no matter at what age she is considered, Mary Marie is always charming," he wrote. "
So is the book."
One review dared to disagree with
Mary Marie's positive receptions. A London
Spectator critic wrote, "The story falls short of what we expect from Miss Eleanor H. Porter."
Although many positive reviews acknowledged the sentimentality of the book (written, as one London Times critic said, in "this American author's usual sprightly, gushing manner."), the reviewers didn't sour on
Mary Marie's sweetness.