Michener wrote over forty books throughout his literary career,
many of them receiving acclaim. He was awarded a Pulitzer Prize
for his first novel, Tales of the South Pacific, and many of his
subsequent novels enjoyed the same level of praise. However,
The Drifters, which was released more or less during the middle of
Michener's career did not follow the example set by its predecessors.
Reviewers found it to be unnecessarily long and trite. He was criticized
for his generic attempts at creating a storyline and his merely
tolerable writing.
"Getting them to Spain is not as easy as it sounds in this notice.
It takes almost 300 pages of Mr. Michener's novel, by which time
the characters introduced earlier have become a little blurred in
the memory. There is a leisureliness to the writing that belongs
to another age."
-Thomas Lask, THE NEW YORK TIMES, June 10, 1971
"The Drifters isn't a long book; it is an interminable one.
Stylistically leaden, thematically tangential, it slogs along
humorlessly for 751 pages masquerading as the definitive report
back to the Middle American parents on what's going on inside their
long-haired, freaky kids' heads."
-Michael Putney, THE NATIONAL OBSERVER, June 7, 1971
"To enjoy the book, the reader must forgive Mr. Michener his
contradictions, fantastic coincidences, and inablility to distinguish
between the need for identification and the struggle for human
understanding. As one of the characters recommends: 'Forgive him.
He's an old man in a new world.'"
-Robin Wright, CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITER, June 24, 1971
The novel was also overshadowed by its time of release which fell only months
after the debut of Kent State: What Happened and Why and Iberia, one of his more
well known works. In the SATURDAY REVIEW, D.W. McCullough writes,
"The Drifters is something of a guidebook loosely dressed up as fiction; a guide to
...the Iberian peninsula, and to the life-styles of the rebellious young.
Mr. Michener has written better about both: in Iberia...and in the recent Kent
State."(May 1, 1971)
While most reviewers were critical of Michener's epic tale, a handful conceeded
that the book might appeal to a less critical audience. Critics commented that he did
seem to have a deeper understanding of the plight of 1970s youth and
praised him for his pursuit in knowing more about an overlooked generation
and his exploration of entertainment for young readers.
"Best selling novelist James Michener has laid claim to an unusually insightful
understanding of youth..."
-Robin Wright, CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITER, June 24, 1971
"The statement of philisophic, social, and political problems is diffuse, but
obvious and will attract readers who do not require subtlety."
-BOOKLIST, July 15, 1971
"It is an interesting trip and Michener is an entertaining as well as
knowledgeable guide. The novel has a more serious purpose, however, which
is exhaustively to examine the 'youth revolution.' Michener brings to
this task narrative skill and a nicely adequate socio-psychological
sophistication."
-Peter Sourian, THE NEW YORK TIMES BOOK REVIEW, June 27, 1971
In examining the success of The Drifters, one cannot overlook that
despite the lack of favorable reception, this novel did become a best
seller and must have been appreciated by more than a couple of readers.
The overly negative reception of The Drifters may have shown that this
was not Michener's best work, but it did not marr Michener's reputation
as a talented writer.
Cumulative Reviews:
BOOKS AND BOOKMEN 10/71
BOOKLIST 7/15/71
BOOKSELLER 6/15/71
BOOKWORLD 7/18/71
BOOKWORLD 6/4/72
CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITER 6/24/71
KIRKUS REVIEWS 4/1/71
LIBRARY JOURNAL 4/1/71
LIFE 6/4/71
LIFE 12/31/71
NATIONAL OBSERVER 6/7/71
NEW YORK TIMES 6/10/71
NEW YORK TIMES BOOK REVIEW 6/27/71
PUBLISHER'S WEEKLY 4/5/71
PUBLISHER'S WEKKLY 3/13/72
SATURDAY REVIEW 5/1/71
SATURDAY REVIEW 5/27/72
SOURCES USED:
Booklist v. 67. Chicago: American Library Associaton Publishing
Board. July 15, 1971, p.931.
Book Review Digest, 1971.
Book Review Index, 1971.
Brown, F.J.. Books and Bookmen v.17. New York: Bowker. April 1,
1971, p.394.
Lask, Thomas. "Live It Up While You Can." The New York Times.
June 10, 1971.
Putney, Michael. "Form Mr. Michener, No Booze But Lots Of Gab."
National Observer. June 7, 1971, p.21.
Readers Guide to Periodical Literature, v.31.
Sourian, Peter. "The Drifters." The New York Times Book Review.
June 27, 1971.
Wright, Robin. "Man Adrift in the Generation Gap." Christian Science
Moniter. June 24, 1971, p.9.
SOURCES NOT USED:
Contemporary Literary Criticism, v.1,5,11.
Twentieth Century Literary Criticism
US News and World Report. Dec 10, 1973, p. 48-55.