1 Paste your critical analysis in here (maximum 2500 words)
Islands in the Stream, by Ernest Hemingway, gained immediate popularity
when it was published in 1970. According to its reviewers, the book
does not owe very much of its popularity to the way that it was written
or to it having a great story. Hemingway wrote the novel several years
before he committed suicide, but he never fully finished it. Hemingway
placed the uncompleted novel in his vault and never looked at it again,
but his wife and close friends knew of its existence and felt they
should put "finishing touches" on it and have it published. Nine years
after Hemingway's death the novel came into print and many people were
very anxious to get their hands on it. Its publication was a triumph for
those who were obsessed with Hemingway because it was Hemingway's last
novel and it had been so many years since anyone had the chance to read
any "new" Hemingway. Nine years after Hemingway's death, in 1970, his
wife Mary and his official biographer Carlos Baker, decided to put the
book into publication. Written mostly in 1951, ten years before the
author shot himself, the book was a mystery to all of his avid readers
(who were many) and many anxiously awaited its publication which greatly
contributed to its enormous popularity.
When Hemingway was alive he had a huge fan-club of readers and at the
time of the publication of Islands in the Stream, this fan-club was
aching for more of Hemingway's fiction. Ernest Hemingway had an
incredible reputation as a novelist in American society throughout his
career. He was affectionately known as "Papa," the father of American
novelists. During the last twenty years of his life, Hemingway's
celebrity most closely resembled that of a movie star and this created
the same effect nine years after his death that watching an old movie
with Gary Cooper would have created--Islands in the Stream allowed all
of the Hemingway fans to return to their hero and favorite writer Ernest
Hemingway. Hemingway practically invented the role of novelist as
celebrity. He was so well known by the American public as well as
internationally. The reputation of Hemingway truly created the novel's
popularity more than anything else. The novelist is the novel's hero
and at the time those who chose to rush out and get the book were doing
so only to satisfy their longing for Hemingway. Hemingway was a highly
stylized writer, so his readers didn't expect surprises but instead
would look for the old solid performance and anticipate the same
"marvelous moves" that first drew them to Hemingway so many years before
Islands in the Stream was published. This book truly served these
purposes for Hemingway's readers--it was a return to their hero who had
so tragically died nearly ten years earlier.
Ernest Hemingway's death by suicide nine years before the novel was
published also effected the book's popularity in many ways. It has been
said that it is impossible to read the novel without thinking of the
author's suicide because so much of the book is about suicide.
Hemingway's family did not want to make it publicly known that he had
committed suicide because that fact greatly threatened his popularity.
It threatened to demolish his work for many of his avid readers because
they looked to Hemingway as being the man whose favorite motto was "il
faut d'abord durer" ( "first of all, endure") --a writer who in so many
novels and stories had stressed physical courage as his crowning virtue.
The fact that Hemingway himself gave up and shot himself in the head
made it appear to his readers that he did not believe in what he
professed in his works and this seemed to be a let-down for his fans.
This most likely had an effect on the strength of his last novel, which
was written during a period of the author's life that was quite
depressing and difficult.
The qualities of the book that were praised by critics were few and far
between. Most critics felt the book was very poorly written and that
it was more "therapy" for its author than a great fictional story. The
book's plot focuses on a man, Thomas Hudson, who has an uncanny
resemblance to Hemingway himself. At the time that Hemingway was
writing this book he was very depressed and contemplating suicide which
he committed ten years later. Some critics say that parts of the novel
were well-written, but for the most part they criticize the books sloppy
organization and long drawn-out sections where relatively nothing
happens at all. The fact that Islands in the Stream depicts the most
depressing part of Hemingway's life contributes to why critics and other
readers felt that the book was more of a disguised autobiography than a
work of magnificent fiction--but people were definitely very interested
in learning what was going on in the head of this famous author and the
book was popular because of that instead of being known as a great work
of fiction.
Despite the sentiments and opinions that the book was poorly written,
the popularity of the book still sky-rocketed when it was published.
This can be attributed to the other factors surrounding the book's
publication, like his popularity and the circumstances of his death that
I have already mentioned. Some other factors influencing the popularity
of the book include when the book was published.
Shortly before Islands in the Stream was published, Carlos baker wrote a
biography on Hemingway and mentioned the existence of the novel. This
biography raised every one of Hemingway's readers' interests and when
the book came out they were anxious to read it. Long excerpts of the
novel's most exciting sections were published in magazines just before
the entire novel was published, so that heightened its popularity when
it his the bookstores. The final version of the novel was published in
October of 1970 and sold 100,000 copies in the first three months and
remained on the best-seller list for a little over a year. Considering
the fact that most critics had nothing good to say about the content of
the novel except that it was important to those who loved and missed
Hemingway, this popularity was strangely acquired.
The book did not remain popular for as long as one might expect coming
from such a greatly known American author. There are several factors
influencing this as well. Immediately after its publication the critics
in major magazines were sharing their opinions that the novel was not
well written. Hemingway himself was not sure if the book should be
published or not. The critics who attacked the novel did not with the
understanding that it was not the author's decision to have the book
published, but at the same time not one critic hesitated in making it
known that the novel was no literary accomplishment. When compared to
Hemingway's other, more successful, works, Islands in the Stream was
almost nothing at all as far as a masterpiece. Some of the author's
other novels, such as Old Man and the Sea and A Farewell to Arms are
still read and taught by many in schools all over the country, but
Islands in the Stream never did achieve such recognition. The reason
this book got the attention that it did was because of the man who wrote
it and because he had been dead for nearly ten years and all of America
was anxious to hear his last story.